Home | Holy Koran | Community Forums | Audio Library | 5 Radio Channels | Koran Recitations | Songs & Naats | Quizzes | Help! | Donate a cup of coffee! | Advertise | Français | بالعربي

Author Topic: The Kite Runner  (Read 1093 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline amr_i_m

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 9
  • Karma: +0/-0
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
The Kite Runner
« on: Friday 28 November 2008, 01:26 »
[size=130%]It is rare to find a Muslim writer getting appreciated for something he has written, but what if he did that and at the same time he revealed part of his culture in it, Khalid el Hosseiny did that in his very nice novel, the kite runner. I invite you to read it and write your feedback here.

There is a way to be good again.

This novel is a very good one, I liked it very much.
It talks about the good and the bad in a strong comparison and at their being very close to each other. It is not the absolute bad, but in the course of life really small mistakes may ruin the whole thing.

Once Amir felt coward and didn't defend hassan and this is how everything changed in life, this reminds me of the movie derailed. When it is very hard to pay for your mistakes. Amir knew very late that Hassan was his brother, and hassan never knew, and this was a single mistake of the father, that he tried to pay it back. The father was always brave and strong, but a single mistake ruined it all.

The story ends at Amir trying to pay back, but after his soul has been torn for his entire life, and after everything was just reminding him of the bad memory.

Something very good about the story, that I got from it a good idea about the writer's country afghanistan, I felt how he is trying to pour his own memories, but without getting you bored, may be because I am seeing people of that community I was keen about that details.

I knew about taliban, and I saw how the religion's decision for adulterers, and how they should be killed that way if they are married, it is a some minutes mistake again, but this is how life goes.

At the end in a very nice dramatic lines Khalid writes a novel that has a real meaning and may affect your view to things.
[/size]

Offline Sami Yusuf Islam

  • Administrator
  • *****
  • Posts: 6884
  • Karma: +0/-0
  • Gender: Male
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #1 on: Friday 28 November 2008, 04:30 »
thank you amr.
 
I wanted to see the film, but found it too rich in graphic violence ....

Offline amr_i_m

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 9
  • Karma: +0/-0
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #2 on: Friday 28 November 2008, 08:30 »
You welcome Sami
I guess the novel is much better than the movie, the novel got a best seller while the movie got nothing.
I still recommend it for you to read.

Offline syd

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 79
  • Karma: +0/-0
  • Gender: Female
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #3 on: Friday 04 December 2009, 07:30 »
 :salam1 have read the novel...but after having read A Thousand Splendid Suns...and believe me that novel is much better than The Kite Runner..on the other hand, Hosseini has written this novel based on the stories that he collected from immigrants, none of these are based on his own observation of facts...Afghanistan has been romanticised over here...its just like Mohsin Hamid writing about a Lahore he has never seen in his book Moth-Smoke while sitting in NYC...and that became a bestseller only because u get to see the amoral side of the muslim society...is that helping the world to see the real picture of who we really are..or just catering to the demands of the people who like to berate muslims, being one themselves...No matter how nice the message be...the book highlights only evil aspects of muslims and almost condones secularism...! btw..im nor pro-Taliban!

Offline amr_i_m

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 9
  • Karma: +0/-0
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #4 on: Friday 04 December 2009, 08:27 »
w Alikom al Salam

Thanks for your kind reply.
I got two advantages from your message.
1) My brother got me thousands splendid suns, but I don't know why I didn't read it. So upon your recommendation I will do that.
2) You added to my info. that Hossani didn't write what he saw in his own eyes. I thought he did, but I was mistaken. I knew he is American, but never knew that he wasn't raised in Afghanstan.

On the other hands, I don't see the book as showing amoral of Muslims, the writer showed his point of view of taliban. Some muslims do agree with it and others don't.

He showed a normal Muslims as normal community, some bad people, others who are brave (like the dad), others who are complete pure (like hassan) and others who are a mix like Amir.

I will be happy if you would recommend other books to me  or join me on good reads.

Thanks,
Amr

Offline amar_labedi

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 131
  • Karma: +0/-0
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #5 on: Saturday 05 December 2009, 02:03 »
 :salam1

mASHALLAH THANKS FOR SHARING....

AMAR

Offline syd

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 79
  • Karma: +0/-0
  • Gender: Female
    • Talk About Islam : Islamic Community Forums for every Muslim!
Re: The Kite Runner
« Reply #6 on: Saturday 05 December 2009, 07:13 »
 :salam1 i hope i didnt offend u by giving my ideas on the book...because after writing the reply i realised that everyone has a right to opinion...! :) im a student of literature...and can recommend a few books but depends on the place u belong to...genreally we like to read either bestsellers or else books written about us, as a nation or country....but offhand...read insomnia by stephan king...nice book..interesting topic too...!its about humans and their auras...and how nothing can tamper with fate and what is predestined! hope it meets with ur approval...
regards

 



keywords: tags: muslim, islam, wife, mariage, meet, match, islamic, moslem, husband, matrimony, sunni, sufi, path, tariqah, tariqa, islam, koran, forum, discuss, talk, chat, dialogue, ask, answer, question, muslim ,moslem, islamic, islamically, halal, haram, sin, duty, obligation, meat, food, ethics, dress, code